TuringTest(Human+religion)=fail?

Please follow my logic and tell me where I go wrong.

1. Let’s say you’re chatting online with a person you’ve never met.  If you are convinced they are a real person then – according to the Turing test – the thing on the other end of the conversation must be at least as smart as you, even if it’s a computer.

2. “Chatbots” fail most often because they repeat themselves and cannot learn or adapt.  Say the same thing 50 times and they will respond the same way 50 times.

3. I was having an argument about the existence of god with a person of faith.  The religious person accepted that my arguments were sound but still insisted that god was real and jesus would save his soul.

4. Doesn’t that person fail the turing test?